On a Sunday in April 2012, in Minneapolis, a group of teenagers from a state school in Brooklyn did something no team like theirs had ever done. They won the United States Chess Federation’s National High School Championship. The remarkable part was not just that they won. It was that they were not a high school team at all.
The players came from Intermediate School 318, a middle school in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, for pupils aged roughly 11 to 14. Most of the team were eighth graders, the equivalent of Year 9. Across the boards sat opponents up to four years older, from some of the most celebrated schools in the country. When the final scores were added up, I.S. 318 had become the first middle school ever to take the title.
A school that turned chess into a source of pride
I.S. 318 is a large neighbourhood school. At the time of the win, more than 60 per cent of its pupils came from families living below the US federal poverty line. It is not the kind of place most people would expect to dominate a game so often associated with private tutors and expensive clubs.
Yet visitors to the school in 2012 found the stairwell landings lined with chess trophies, some of them four feet tall. The New York Times reported that the school’s celebrities were its chess players, and that the classroom where they trained was full of noisy, high-speed games played with the energy of a hockey match.
It had not always been that way. According to the school’s chess coordinator, the programme began in 1997 as a small club called the “Chess Nuts”, with around ten pupils. Two years later, a young chess player named Elizabeth Spiegel (then Elizabeth Vicary) arrived to coach one day a week through a New York charity that runs chess in schools.
From beginners’ sections to national champions
The early results were modest, and Spiegel has always been honest about that. The team’s first trip, in 2000, was to a tournament in Tucson, Arizona. It was the first overnight trip the school had ever taken, let alone one by plane. They won the section for beginners. The following year they won two sections, and the year after that three.
What changed things was steady, unglamorous work. The team went to a tournament almost every Saturday. The programme grew in size and quality each year. Eventually the school’s principal offered Spiegel a permanent job if she gained her teaching licence, so she went back to university to earn one, teaching in the meantime partly as a volunteer. By 2007 she was the school’s full-time chess teacher, running year-long chess classes in which pupils did homework, sat tests and earned grades, just as they would in any other subject.
The trophies followed. By the time of the 2012 win, the school had collected dozens of national titles, and in 2009 its pupils won the sixth, seventh and eighth-grade titles at the national scholastic championships. In 2011 the team came second at the high school nationals. A year later, they went one better.
The weekend in Minneapolis
The 2012 championship was close. I.S. 318 finished level on points with Hunter College High School, a highly selective New York school that had won the title for the two previous years, and took the trophy on tiebreaks. Along the way they finished ahead of famous names including Stuyvesant High School in Manhattan.
The team was led by Justus Williams and James Black Jr, both 13 and both already rated as chess masters, alongside Isaac Barayev and Matthew Kluska. The US Chess Federation’s own tournament report put it simply: what made the victory striking was that this was a middle school team.
“Losing is something you do, not something you are”
So what was happening in that classroom? The most detailed answer comes from the journalist Paul Tough, who spent months with the team for his book How Children Succeed.
Tough found that Spiegel did not follow a fixed chess curriculum. Instead, she planned lessons around what her pupils had just got wrong. If she noticed at a weekend tournament that many of them were leaving pieces undefended, the whole of Monday’s lesson would be about not doing that. She would set up their actual games on large boards at the front of the room and replay them move by move: where did it go wrong, what else could you have done, and what would have happened next?
After every tournament game, win or lose, players came back to the team room to go through it with her. Spiegel told Tough that this kind of study is uncomfortable, because it means focusing hard on what you are bad at. She also tried to teach pupils to take responsibility for their mistakes without being crushed by them. “I try to teach my students that losing is something you do, not something you are,” she said.
She was not a soft touch. Tough describes her telling a talented player, bluntly, that he had thrown away a winning game by moving too quickly, and then, moments later, praising his clever ideas elsewhere on the board. Her job, as she saw it, was to be “more like a mirror”: to look seriously at a young person’s work, on a non-condescending level, and help them think about it.
One of the school’s players, Carlos Tapia, later told the New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof that “chess teaches me self-control”, and that it spilled over into his other schoolwork.
Why the story still matters
The I.S. 318 team became the subject of a documentary, Brooklyn Castle, released in 2012. But the lasting lesson is not really about chess. It is about what happens when a school takes one activity seriously, gives it proper time, celebrates success openly, and treats every mistake as information rather than failure.
None of it happened overnight. It took more than a decade of Saturdays, a teacher willing to retrain, and a school prepared to put trophies on the stairs and chess on the timetable.
What we can take into our classroom
- Plan from the mistakes. Use the errors pupils actually made last lesson as the starting point for the next one, rather than moving on regardless.
- Make reviewing a habit, not a punishment. A short, regular “post-mortem” on a piece of work, win or lose, teaches pupils that mistakes are useful.
- Separate the mistake from the child. Spiegel’s line, “losing is something you do, not something you are”, is worth putting on the wall.
- Teach pupils to slow down. Many errors come from rushing. Build in a moment to check before an answer is final.
- Take their work seriously. Pupils notice when an adult really looks at what they have produced and talks to them about it honestly.
- Celebrate visibly. I.S. 318 put its trophies where everyone walked past them. Displaying achievement tells pupils what the school values.
- Play the long game. The team started in the beginners’ section. Small, steady progress over years can add up to something extraordinary.
Sources
- The New York Times – At Brooklyn’s I.S. 318, the Cool Kids Are the Chess Champs (17 April 2012)
- US Chess Federation – Skywalk to Chess: The National High School Champs (April 2012)
- Our Time Press – Local middle school chess team wins national championship (19 April 2012)
- JTA – ‘I Like To Attack’ (24 April 2012)
- The Chess Drum – I.S. 318 are H.S. Champs! (16 April 2012)
- Chalkbeat – Exclusive excerpt: Paul Tough’s “How Children Succeed” (5 September 2012)
- Paul Tough – How Children Succeed (book page and excerpt)
- The New York Times – Nicholas Kristof, Meet the Champs (31 January 2013)
- PBS POV – Brooklyn Castle: film description
- Brooklyn Castle press notes (First Run Features, PDF)
Categorised in: Ibbleobble
This post was written by kidd78

